Vagrantsong Expansion vs Scenario Expansion: What to Buy
By Wyrd Games Official Store | Tabletop Games & Miniatures | Published: 2026-10-16
Category: Buying Guides
Compare Vagrantsong expansions and scenario expansions by what they actually add. Use clear decision rules to pick the right box for your table.
Quick answer
Buy a scenario expansion when you want new story content, bosses, and scenarios that change how you play the core game. Buy a full Vagrantsong expansion when you want a larger, more varied content drop with new mechanics and components. If you only want more of what you already love, start with a scenario expansion; if you want a bigger shift in the game, choose a full expansion.
What each type actually adds
A scenario expansion adds new scenarios, story branches, and often new bosses or encounter rules. It plugs into your existing core set and assumes you already own the base game. A full Vagrantsong expansion typically introduces a larger set of new content, which can include new mechanics, new components, and more replay variety. The practical difference is scope: scenario expansions are focused add-ons, while full expansions are broader content packages. If you are unsure which one you are looking at, check the product description for whether it says it requires the core game and whether it lists scenarios or a larger rules addition.
How to choose without wasting money
Start by asking what is missing from your current sessions. If you have played the core scenarios repeatedly and want fresh narrative twists, a scenario expansion is the efficient buy. If you feel the whole game needs more mechanical variety and you are ready to learn new systems, a full expansion is the better fit. Do not buy a full expansion just because it is bigger; bigger means more rules overhead and more shelf space. Also check whether the expansion is designed for the player count you actually play at, and whether it adds content you will realistically use. If your group meets rarely, a scenario expansion gives you a focused new experience without asking you to relearn the whole game.
Accessories and storage: the hidden cost
Expansions add cards, tokens, and sometimes miniatures, so storage and protection matter more after you buy. Sleeving cards keeps them usable across many plays, and a dedicated box or insert prevents bent components. If you already use a Fate Deck or similar card accessories, check that new cards fit your current sleeve size before buying. For miniatures, plan for safe storage if you paint them; chipping and dust are common problems, so a case or foam tray is a practical add-on. These costs are small compared to the expansion itself, but they affect whether the new content actually gets played.
Decision rules for Vagrantsong expansions
- You want new story, not new systems: Choose a scenario expansion. It adds scenarios and narrative content that slot into the core game without requiring you to relearn the base rules. Best if you already enjoy the core loop and just want more of it.
- You want a broader mechanical change: Choose a full expansion. It is designed to add more substantial content, which usually means new rules and components alongside scenarios. Best if your group is ready for a bigger rules and setup commitment.
- You are unsure which product is which: Check whether the listing says it requires the core game and whether it lists scenarios or a larger rules addition. That distinction tells you the scope before you buy. If the description is vague, ask the store or check the publisher page before ordering.
Products that support expansion play
- Evil Baby Orphanage: Fate Deck: Use this illustrated deck with Evil Baby Orphanage, Malifaux, Puppet Wars, and other Wyrd games that use a standard Fate Deck. If your group already plays Wyrd games that use a standard Fate Deck, this deck is a cross-compatible accessory rather than a single-game purchase.
- Malifaux Third Edition: Iconic - Scorch the Soul: The large display sculpt gives painters room to push texture, contrast, lighting, and storytelling, while the smaller preassembled version carries the same character. If you want a display piece alongside your game, the large sculpt rewards painting time; the smaller version is ready to use sooner.
Who should buy which
Best for
- Players who own the core game and want focused new scenarios without a rules overhaul
- Groups that play occasionally and prefer content they can add in one session
- Buyers who want to expand a Wyrd Games collection with compatible card accessories
Not for
- Players who do not own the core Vagrantsong game yet
- Groups looking for a completely new standalone game rather than an add-on
- Buyers who want only miniatures and no new scenarios or rules
